SKLearn NMF Vs Custom NMF

0 votes

I am trying to build a recommendation system using Non-negative matrix factorization. Using scikit-learn NMF as the model, I fit my data, resulting in a certain loss(i.e., reconstruction error). Then I generate recommendation for new data using the inverse_transform method.

Now I do the same using another model I built in TensorFlow. The reconstruction error after training is close to that obtained using sklearn's approach earlier. However, neither are the latent factors similar to one another nor the final recommendations.

One difference between the 2 approaches that I am aware of is: In sklearn, I am using the Coordinate Descent solver whereas in TensorFlow, I am using the AdamOptimizer which is based on Gradient Descent. Everything else seems to be the same:

  1. Loss function used is the Frobenius Norm
  2. No regularization in both cases
  3. Tested on the same data using same number of latent dimensions

Relevant code that I am using:

1. scikit-learn approach:

model =  NMF(alpha=0.0, init='random', l1_ratio=0.0, max_iter=200, 
n_components=2, random_state=0, shuffle=False, solver='cd', tol=0.0001, 
verbose=0)
model.fit(data)
result = model.inverse_transform(model.transform(data))

2. TensorFlow approach:

w = tf.get_variable(initializer=tf.abs(tf.random_normal((data.shape[0], 
2))), constraint=lambda p: tf.maximum(0., p))
h = tf.get_variable(initializer=tf.abs(tf.random_normal((2, 
data.shape[1]))), constraint=lambda p: tf.maximum(0., p))
loss = tf.sqrt(tf.reduce_sum(tf.squared_difference(x, tf.matmul(w, h))))

My question is that if the recommendations generated by these 2 approaches do not match, then how can I determine which are the right ones? Based on my use case, sklearn's NMF is giving me good results, but not the TensorFlow implementation. How can I achieve the same using my custom implementation?

Sep 14, 2018 in Python by bug_seeker
• 15,300 points
45 views

1 answer to this question.

Your answer

Your name to display (optional):
Privacy: Your email address will only be used for sending these notifications.
0 votes

The choice of the optimizer has a big impact on the quality of the training. Some very simple models (I'm thinking of GloVe for example) do work with some optimizer and not at all with some others. Then, to answer your questions:

  1. how can I determine which are the right ones ?

The evaluation is as important as the design of your model, and it is as hard i.e. you can try these 2 models and several available datasets and use some metrics to score them. You could also use A/B testing on a real case application to estimate the relevance of your recommendations.

  1. How can I achieve the same using my custom implementation ?

First, try to find a coordinate descent optimizer for Tensorflow and make sure all step you implemented are exactly the same as the one in scikit-learn. Then, if you can't reproduce the same, try different solutions (why don't you try a simple gradient descent optimizer first ?) and take profit of the great modularity that Tensorflow offers !

answered Sep 14, 2018 by Priyaj
• 56,140 points

Related Questions In Python

0 votes
1 answer

SKLearn NMF Vs Custom NMF

The choice of the optimizer has a ...READ MORE

answered May 9, 2018 in Python by charlie_brown
• 7,710 points
249 views
0 votes
1 answer

Difference between append vs. extend list methods in Python

append: Appends object at end. x = [1, ...READ MORE

answered Jun 4, 2018 in Python by ariaholic
• 7,320 points
123 views
+2 votes
2 answers

Compiled vs Interpreted Languages

Compiled languages are written in a code ...READ MORE

answered Dec 3, 2018 in Python by allenvarna
• 520 points
187 views
0 votes
1 answer

Difference between append vs. extend list methods in Python

append: Appends object at the end. x = ...READ MORE

answered Aug 8, 2018 in Python by bug_seeker
• 15,300 points
62 views
0 votes
1 answer

how can i count the items in a list?

suppose you have a list a = [0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10] now ...READ MORE

answered May 2 in Python by Mohammad
• 1,400 points
56 views
0 votes
1 answer

SKLearn NMF Vs Custom NMF

The choice of the optimizer has a ...READ MORE

answered Sep 7, 2018 in Python by Priyaj
• 56,140 points
26 views
0 votes
1 answer

Python string formatting: % vs. .format

To answer your first question... .format just ...READ MORE

answered Aug 17, 2018 in Python by Priyaj
• 56,140 points
18 views

© 2018 Brain4ce Education Solutions Pvt. Ltd. All rights Reserved.
"PMP®","PMI®", "PMI-ACP®" and "PMBOK®" are registered marks of the Project Management Institute, Inc. MongoDB®, Mongo and the leaf logo are the registered trademarks of MongoDB, Inc.