How do you handle a negatively disruptive unethical team member who is also a star performer with a virtually irreplaceable and critical skill-set

0 votes

Samuel is a star project performer, with a unique and very rare skill-set critical to your project. He comes up with brilliant ideas and is extremely productive.A dream project contributor, right? Not entirely.

Samuel is terribly arrogant, publicly humiliates other team members, and constantly causes conflicts by spreading baseless rumours.

Worse, he was recently proven to claim credit for another team member's work, and in the past, pilfering.

As Project Manager, this seems to be a "lose-lose" situation:

  • Keep Samuel in the team, and team morale suffers, bringing down overall productivity.

  • Releasing him will create a situation where critical tasks would be delayed, that would endanger the project.

Have you been in a similar situation? Is there a "win-win" way?
 

Aug 7, 2020 in PMP by anonymous
• 19,610 points
96 views

1 answer to this question.

0 votes
I would suggest having a 1:1 discussion with Samuel. Assuming you already attempted it to little avail, so based on your description, Samuel's behavior is breaking policy, not just "good team behavior" rules.

This is an HR issue for his people manager.

If there is no willingness from HR or his manager to do anything, probably think of getting him removed.

While there might be some effects on the project, the effects on the project team and associated stakeholders will persist far beyond the life of the project if you keep him around.
answered Aug 7, 2020 by Kiron

Related Questions In PMP

+1 vote
1 answer

How do I become a Project manager with no experience?

Since you don't have any prior experience ...READ MORE

answered Jul 22, 2020 in PMP by Sirajul
• 59,070 points
162 views
+1 vote
1 answer

Is Project Management a good career?

Definitely, project management is a great career ...READ MORE

answered Jul 23, 2020 in PMP by Sirajul
• 59,070 points
173 views
+1 vote
1 answer

Perfect Project Manager

In my view, perfection is impossible for ...READ MORE

answered Jul 29, 2020 in PMP by Louis
106 views
0 votes
1 answer
0 votes
1 answer

Project management skills in a digital era

From a digital transformation perspective, I strongly ...READ MORE

answered Aug 7, 2020 in PMP by Keith
112 views